Best Ice Fishing Lures for Panfish of 2023

Nicole Stone

Ice fishing for panfish is wildly popular, thanks to the accessibility of the species and the action-packed experience they provide. If you want to hit the ice for crappie, bluegill, or perch, you’ll need the right gear. I’ve made that a little easier by choosing the best ice fishing lures for panfish using my years of experience catching these species. 

• Best for Crappie: Crappie Mo’ Glo Jig
• Best for Bluegill: Lindy Tungsten Toad
• Best for Perch: Northland Forage Minnow
• Best for Tough Bite Days: VMC Bullfly
• Best for Aggressive Bites: Lindy Rattl’N Flyer Spoons
• Best Lure for When Nothing Else Is Working: Rapala Jigging Rap

Best Ice Fishing Lures for Panfish: Reviews & Recommendations

Best Lure for Crappie: Crappie Mo’ Glo Jig

Key Features

• Balanced presentation
• Long shank that works well with plastics
• Distinct glow finish
• Tapered hook made specifically for crappie

Pros

• Glow
• Balanced presentation
• Tempered for crappie fishing
• Ideal for ice and open water presentations
• Works well with bait and artificials

Cons

• Large hook doesn’t pair well with spikes and smaller baits 
• Environmental concerns regarding the use of lead
• On an aggressive bite, the slow fall rate can cost you fish

Product Description 

The Mo’ Glo Jig hits the mark on many must-have features of a quality panfish lure. For example, it has a balanced horizontal presentation that fits well with minnow bodies and plastics. It’s high-gloss finish helps accentuate the lure’s glow properties, allowing it to stand out in lowlight conditions that are often best for crappie fishing. Additionally, its wide-gap chrome hook is tapered specifically for crappie, which helps hooksets and eliminates the chance of losing a trophy fish.   

Its lead composition also allows it to have a slow, enticing fall relative to its size. This can produce a competitive bite—something frequently overlooked by panfish anglers. Perhaps most importantly, it pairs well with plastics. When you can fish plastics, you spend more time fishing and less replacing baiting. 

Read Next: Ice Fishing for Panfish: The Best Tips and Tactics

I personally like a 1/16 ounce jig in ghost or chartreuse colors, paired with a minnow body or your favorite crappie plastic. If you happen to see the hard-to-find 1/32 ounce jig still on a shelf, even better. Be sure to work this bait above a school of feasting crappies to wean out the bigger fish. 

Best Lure for Bluegill: Lindy Tungsten Toad

Key Features

• Dense tungsten composition
• Horizontal presentation
• A variety of colors and hook sizes
• Durable

Pros

• Greater sensitivity than lead jigs
• Faster fall rates
• Easy to break through slush
• Get in front of the school faster
• Hangs horizontal which allows for a natural presentation 
• Perfect for finesse fishing in midwinter

Cons

• Tough bite days might require a faster fall rate
• Not the best choice for shallow water

The Lindy Tungsten Toad is a tough and reliable bait that should be in every ice angler’s arsenal. Its main benefit is that its dense tungsten composition falls faster than lead counterparts of the same size. This means anglers can downsize without reducing weight. When targeting bluegill, this can be especially important. The Tungsten Toad comes in a multitude of glow and non-colors, as well as three hook sizes—sizes 10, 12, and 14. 

Read Next: The Best Walleye Lures

I pair my Tungsten Toads with wax worms or very small plastics. In most situations, I prefer a size 12 hook because it’s large enough to weed out small fish but small enough to entice bluegill. When paired with bait I use a slow dance and raise. During tough bite days, I downsize to a size 14 hook and waxworms to turn over more fish. 

Best Lure for Perch: Northland Forage Minnow

Key Features

• Miniature jigging spoon (can be found down to a size 1/32 ounce)
• Lifelike holographic pattern
• Flashes and flutters

Pros

• Mimics a small, crippled minnow
• Comes in a large variety of colors and patterns
• Versatile, multi-species lure

Cons

• Concerns with weak hooks 

The Northland Forage Minnow is a perfect spoon for targeting jumbo perch. Not only does it have a lifelike holographic pattern in a variety of popular perch patterns, but it also can be purchased as small as 1/32 ounce, making it a very versatile spoon for many different areas.

Best Lure for Tough Bite Days: VMC Bullfly

Key Features

• Tungsten jig head
• Horizontal presentation
• Comes in a variety of metallic and glow colors
• Premium goose tail and wing

Pros

• Can be purchased in extremely small sizes (1/64 ounce)
• Wide gap hook to secure more hooksets
• Horizontal presentation

Cons

• Small hook 

The VMC Tungsten Bullfly Jig is a small, compact package that comes in a variety of colors, including glow and metallic patterns. Its feather tail and wings help it mimic bugs and small forage in the water. This is key during those midwinter days, when the bite gets more finicky. 

I always keep a variety of 1/16, 1/32, and 1/64 ounce jigs in metallic silver and metallic gold on hand. I tip them with spikes and work them up slowly through the water column. When using that technique, you’ll be surprised by how many crappies, bluegill and perch you can catch on this little jig.  

Best Lure for Aggressive Bites: Lindy Rattl’N Flyer Spoons

Key Features

• Made of non-lead alloy
• Unique wing profile provides erratic jigging actions
• Built-in rattle
• Red treble
• Glow eyes

Pros

• Dances, darts, and glides, providing a variety of action
• Comes in lifelike baitfish patterns
• Holographic finish

Cons

• Lightest weight is 1/16 ounce
• The presentation is too aggressive to catch small panfish

The Lindy Rattl’N Flyer Spoon is a perfect lure for nearly any species thanks to its unique wing structure and built-in rattles. Its erratic return and aggressive behavior is popular among predator anglers. However, when downsized to the 1/16 ounce size, it can be one of the best ice fishing lures for panfish, specifically for the largest and most aggressive panfish. Its lifelike patterns and variation of colors allows you to match the hatch. It’s especially effective tipped with a minnow head or some spikes.

Read Next: The Best Bass Lures

This flyer spoon has caught me some big crappie and jumbo perch because in trophy fisheries often create an environment conducive to an aggressive bite. That’s why when targeting fish on a trophy destination, don’t be afraid to throw out a more aggressive bait such as a Lindy Rattl’N Flyer Spoon, and watch as you pick off the largest and most aggressive fish in the school. 

Best Lure for When Nothing Else Is Working: Rapala Jigging Rap

Key Features

• Balanced design
• Minnow profile
• Creates a reaction bite
• Comes in natural, UV, and glow color

Pros

• Has an erratic response to snap jigging
• No bait needed
• High landing percentage

Cons

• Takes time to master the technique
• Snagging can be an issue if fishing over structure

The Jigging Rap is a staple for walleye fishing. However, what many people don’t realize is how deadly it can be one of the best ice fishing lures for panfish. There are times when the only thing that will work is the snap jigging technique (quick snaps with a varied cadence). This technique, paired with the Jigging Rap’s realistic profile and perfect snap jigging response, can be the trigger on those days when nothing else seems to be working. Not to mention, when competition is a factor, the biggest fish will often chase the most aggressive lures. This is when the jigging rap really shines. 

Sizes 2, 3, and 5 are best when targeting panfish. Best of all, bait is not needed, meaning more time in the water and less time wasted baiting your hook. When working the Jigging Rap, focus on a varied cadence.  

Choosing the Best Ice Fishing Rod for Panfish 

Picking the right lure is critical for increasing your odds while targeting panfish, but ultimately the best way to land more panfish is to lighten up your gear. An ultralight or noodle rod will allow for the lightest detection in bite while also allowing you to control lightweight baits. This is especially important when using baits like the Lindy Tungsten Toad, Crappie Pro Mo’ Glo Jig, and VMC Bullfly.  

 Make sure to also pair your presentation with a light line. I prefer 2- to 4-pound monofilament for crappie and bluegill, but braid and fluorocarbon will do too. Many perch anglers prefer braid, as its stiffer composition and added sensitivity assist in enticing and detecting the perch bite off of the bottom. Most importantly, it helps you detect a bite. The sensitivity on the end of the rod allows you to see the lightest interaction with the bait and respond with a hookset. 

FAQs

Why Trust Outdoor Life?

Since 1898, OL has been a leading authority in testing and reviewing hunting gear, fishing tackle, guns and shooting equipment, and much more. We have more than a century-long history of evaluating products, and we’re now bringing that expertise to online reviews. Our editors are experienced outdoorsmen and women, and most importantly, we’re trained journalists. We prioritize field testing and objective data when reviewing products. We conduct interviews with gear manufacturers and engineers as well as outdoor experts so that our readers have an understanding of how and why a product works—or doesn’t.

Advertising does not influence our gear reviews and it never will. While we always focus our coverage on standout products—because we want our readers to be aware of the latest and greatest gear—we also cover the flaws and quirks of any given product.

Final Thoughts

When choosing the best ice fishing lure for panfish, it’s easy to get overwhelmed by the long aisles of colors and sizes, but you can feel well prepared having these options in your tackle box. 

• Best for Crappie: Crappie Mo’ Glo Jig
• Best for Bluegill: Lindy Tungsten Toad
• Best for Perch: Northland Forage Minnow
• Best for Tough Bite Days: VMC Bullfly
• Best for Aggressive Bites: Lindy Rattl’N Flyer Spoons
• Best Lure for When Nothing Else Is Working: Rapala Jigging Rap

The post Best Ice Fishing Lures for Panfish of 2023 appeared first on Outdoor Life.

Articles may contain affiliate links which enable us to share in the revenue of any purchases made.

Source: https://www.outdoorlife.com/gear/best-ice-fishing-lures-for-panfish/